What the Tribunal Decided
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal ruled on 19 November 2026 that the Home Office has not shown that confirming a technical capability notice to Apple would damage national security. Three judges, Lady Carmichael, Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson, heard the open part on 17 September 2026 in two linked claims, one from Apple and one from Liberty and Privacy International. The open judgment says authorised confirmations had been given to newspapers and that Apple was allowed to brief US officials, so anyone with a passing interest already knows the notice exists. According to TechCrunch the Home Office has not yet confirmed the order, and the Tribunal also issued private and closed judgments that stay unpublished.
What Stays Secret
The ruling covers the fact of the notice, not its content. The Tribunal accepts that some detail may never be public and says the line can only be drawn after both sides exchange evidence. Apple's second claim, filed in July 2026, rests on five grounds, among them whether the power can be used to regulate the security services a company offers its customers and whether Apple was treated differently from other firms. A December 2026 hearing is impractical, so the parties are working towards the first half of 2027. TechCrunch reports that Apple refused the first order, stopped UK users switching on Advanced Data Protection for iCloud, and that a narrower second order is also under challenge.
What an Owner Should Do
Nothing in the judgment changes what Apple devices do today, so plan for the next silent order and not for this one. List which client or staff data sits in cloud backups the vendor can read, because a notice served on a vendor reaches data it can decrypt and not data it cannot. Move your most sensitive files, such as contracts and client records, into tools that encrypt before upload with keys you hold, and check that UK staff are not relying on Advanced Data Protection, which is unavailable to them. Add the question of whether a vendor could be served a silent order to your next supplier review under UK GDPR or GDPR.
Read next: Germany Banned This Ad. Today, So Does the EU. | The Investor Behind Apple's $5.7B Verdict



