Two Votes, Nine Days Apart
On Tuesday, 7 July 2026, MEPs approved an urgent procedure that forced a second vote on extending Chat Control 1.0, the temporary rule letting messaging and webmail providers scan private communications for suspected child sexual abuse material. That procedural vote passed 331 to 304, with 11 abstentions, over public objections that it reopened a file Parliament had already rejected once, back in March 2026, when the previous extension lapsed and the scanning permission expired in April.
That set up Thursday's vote, on 9 July, under Parliament's second-reading rules for a Council position. Rejecting or amending the Council's text at that stage requires an absolute majority of all sitting MEPs, not simply more votes for than against among those present. Ahead of the procedural vote, Greens/EFA negotiator Markéta Gregorová warned MEPs that reopening a file this way "violates our own rules of procedure."
Why 314 Did Not Win
Thursday's tally looked, at first glance, like Chat Control 1.0 lost. A majority of MEPs who voted, 314 against 276, backed the motion to reject extending the scanning derogation, with 17 abstentions. Under a simple-majority test, that margin would have ended the extension outright.
| Result | Votes |
|---|---|
| For rejecting the extension | 314 |
| Against rejecting (for keeping it) | 276 |
| Abstained | 17 |
| Absolute majority required to block it | 360 |
Second-reading rules erase that margin. Rejecting or amending a Council position at this stage needs an absolute majority of the European Parliament's full membership, currently 360 votes, regardless of how many MEPs actually turn up. The rejection motion fell 46 votes short of that bar, so under the EU's ordinary legislative procedure the second reading closed automatically and the Council's position was deemed adopted, without Parliament ever casting a vote in favor of its substance.
What Comes Next: 2028 and a September Reopening
The derogation Parliament failed to reject stays in force until 3 April 2028, giving messaging, webmail and other communications providers a multi-year legal basis to keep scanning private messages for suspected CSAM if they choose to. The same package folded in an amendment from the liberal Renew group excluding communications "to which end-to-end encryption is, has been, or will be applied" from the scanning rules, a change some MEPs credited with tipping enough votes against rejection that the wider text survived.
None of this settles the permanent successor, Chat Control 2.0, which stays separate from the derogation just extended and returns to trilogue negotiations between Parliament, Council and Commission in September 2026. Patrick Breyer, a digital rights advocate and former MEP who has tracked the file for years, argues Parliament should hold out for detection orders targeted at named suspects instead of blanket scanning of everyone's messages. Lyudmyla Kozlovska, president of the Open Dialogue Foundation, put the stakes plainly: the real fight over encryption and communications privacy is in September, and opponents have until then to organize resistance strong enough that, in her words, "no procedural trick can carry it."
The Compliance Read: Track the Threshold, Not the Tally
For an EU compliance or product team monitoring Chat Control 2.0, the headline vote count is close to useless on its own. A story of "314 MEPs opposed it" says nothing about whether that opposition can actually stop the measure, because the answer depends entirely on which procedural stage the file sits at and what majority that stage demands.
Servola's read is structural, not just about this one derogation: whenever a supermajority is required to reject a default outcome, an opposed majority can lose while a minority effectively wins, simply because it needed fewer votes to hold its position than its opponents needed to break it. Chat Control 2.0's September trilogues are the next point where that mechanic could repeat, so the operational task is not reading vote-count headlines as a verdict, but tracking, at each remaining stage, whether the threshold in play is a simple majority, an absolute majority, or something else entirely.
Read next: A Freight Giant's Unit Faces a Chip Smuggling Probe | Momenta Beat Waymo to Germany's KBA Approval
